Compare and contrast 'to his coy mistress' and 'the passionate shepherd to his love' both of these poems explore the theme of love between a man and a woman the desired outcome is the two arguments are close to being completely the opposite even though they are trying to achieve similar things the period in. Get an answer for 'what are some comparisons and contrasts between the passionate shepherd to his love by christopher marlowe and the nymph's reply to the shepherd by sir on the other hand, the two poems are quite similar because the reply is a mirror, or perhaps an older, wiser echo of the proposal poem. Christopher marlowe is considered to be he wrote the poem the passionate shepherd to his love in which the character expresses his true affection through his loving words, actions he will take, and raleigh, like marlowe, used strong words to portray the nymph's affection, or actually lack there of, to the shepherd. Come live with me and be my love, and we will all the pleasures prove that valleys, groves, hills, and fields, woods, or steepy mountain yields and we will sit upon the rocks, seeing the shepherds feed their flocks, by shallow rivers to whose falls melodious birds sing madrigals and i will make thee beds of roses and a.
The passionate shepherd to his love is a pastoral lyric, a poetic form that is used to create an idealized vision of rural life within the context of personal emotion pastoral poems had been in vogue among poets for at least seventeen hundred years when marlowe wrote this one the greek poet theocritis,. The idea of music and making the most of love put me in mind of a different poem from elizabethan times, written by an alleged rival of shakespeare's, christopher marlowe the passionate shepherd to his love by christopher marlowe come live with me and be my love, and we will all the pleasures. Christopher marlow poem the passionate shepherd to his love with literary analysis, structural analysis, and guidance for usage of quotes the poet has used a word pun in the next phrase “a thousand fragrant posies” where “posies” has a double meaning: it both refers to poetry as well as a bunch of flowers in. In the poems the passionate shepherd to his love by christopher marlowe and song by c day lewis, the speakers display their individual views of what can be expected with their love both speakers produce invitations to love with differences in what they have to offer a list of promised delights is offered by the.
The passionate shepherd to his love (unknown date), stanzas 1 and 2 compare: to shallow rivers, to whose falls / melodious birds sings madrigals / there will we make our peds of roses, / and a thousand fragrant posies, william shakespeare, merry wives of windsor for both their worths shall equal him no more. The writer of a pastoral poem may be an educated city dweller, like marlowe, who extolls the virtues of a shepherd girl or longs for the peace and quiet of the of the word madrigals (line 8)—referring to poems set to music and sung by two to six voices with a single melody or interweaving melodies—suggests that the time. Free essay: comparing the passionate shepherd to his love and nymph's reply to the shepherd and the stark contrast of the treatment of an identical theme interpretation of the poem, reflects a response to the life marlowe has lived so far and his reaction to it the poem is written as a love poem but if you look more.
The passionate shepherd to his love by christopher marlowe 1599 come live with me and be my love, and we will all the pleasures prove the themes of the poem - carpe diem and the immediate gratification of their sexual passions love in the may countryside will be like a return to the garden of eden there is a. We know from the title that this poem is a response, or reply, to someone and/or something else that's already been written—in this case christopher marlowe's poem, the passionate shepherd to his love reading marlowe's poem is pretty essential to understanding what ralegh is doing with his response, but even. Study of romantic love comparison and analysis are the chief tools of the critic --ts eliot abstract: christopher marlowe and kazi nazrul islam are very much similar in expressing their romantic love in their two songs “the passionate shepherd to his love‟‟ and “my love” respectively in both songs, romantic zeal is.
Come live with me and be my love, and we will all the pleasures prove that hills and vallies, dales and fields, woods or steepy mountain yields. The poems both have a similar ploy they are both trying to lure a lady into a life of love however the speaker's about this in different ways marlowe's vision of love in 'a passionate shepherd' is very sweet, charming and delightful whereas in contrast marvell's vision in 'to his coy mistress' is one of. Written only a year apart, christopher marlowe's the passionate shepherd to his love (1599) and its seemingly contradictory retort, sir walter raleigh's the nymph's reply to the shepherd when reading these two poems one after the other, one of the first things the reader should notice is the two contrasting tones.
In this lesson, students consider the full texts of marlowe's “the passionate shepherd to his love” and raleigh's “the nymph's reply to the shepherd” as they explore how r9, analyze how two or more texts address similar themes or topics in order to build knowledge or to compare the approaches the authors take.
Attanayake, pavitra m, identical hearts, different rhythms: the various viewpoints of marlowe, raleigh, and dickinson (2015) “the passionate shepherd to his love,” a love poem written by christopher marlowe initiates a dickinson's “i cannot live with you” was also written as a response to the works of the two. “the passionate shepherd to his love” by christopher marlowe, and “the nymph's reply to the shepherd” by sir walter raleigh there are many poems that are considered to be companion poems companion poems are two separate poems that are similar usually they are about the same experience or experiences. Comparison between 'the passionate shepherd to his love' by christopher marlowe and 'the nymph's reply to the shepherd' by sir walter raleigh looking closely on both poems, one realizes that the arrangement of these two poems is the same where both have six stanzas comprising of four lines.